Blog
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.
Understanding the Taxation of Lawsuit Settlements: What Taxpayers Need to Know
Receiving proceeds from a lawsuit settlement can significantly impact your financial situation, and understanding the tax implications is crucial for effective financial planning. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) provides comprehensive guidelines on how to determine the taxability of different components of a settlement, which can include compensation for physical injuries, emotional distress, lost wages, attorney fees, and more. This article explores these aspects, emphasizing the tax treatment and the deductibility of attorney fees, ultimately influencing the net settlement proceeds received by taxpayers.
Tax Treatment of Settlement Proceeds
The tax treatment of settlement proceeds hinges on the nature of the underlying claim. Understanding these categories will help you see what needs to be included in the wording of the claim and settlement, and ultimately how much will be reportable in your taxable income:
Personal Physical Injuries or Physical Sickness: Proceeds received from a settlement due to personal physical injuries or physical sickness are generally non-taxable. However, if you previously deducted medical expenses related to these injuries and received a tax benefit, that portion becomes taxable. This amount is reported as other income on the Form 1040.
Emotional Distress or Mental Anguish: Payments received for emotional distress or mental anguish are taxable unless they arise directly from a physical injury or sickness. If they do not originate from a physical condition, the taxable amount can be reduced by the medical expenses associated with emotional distress if such expenses were not previously deducted or were deducted without a tax benefit.
Lost Wages or Lost Profits: Settlements that cover lost wages, such as those from employment-related lawsuits (e.g., wrongful termination or discrimination), are taxable as wages and are subject to employment taxes. They should be reported on Line 1a of Form 1040. Similarly, settlements for lost business profits are subject to self-employment tax, since they are considered business income.
Punitive Damages: Punitive damages are financial compensation awarded to a plaintiff in a lawsuit that goes beyond what is necessary to compensate for losses. They are intended to punish the defendant for egregious or wrongful conduct and to deter similar actions in the future. These damages are distinguished from compensatory damages, which are meant solely to compensate the injured party for actual losses or harm suffered.
Punitive damages are always taxable because they are considered a form of income under the Internal Revenue Code. The tax treatment aligns with the principle that these damages are not compensating for any physical injury or loss but rather serve as a financial penalty against the defendant. Since they are not linked to any personal injury or health condition, they do not fall under the non-taxable category typically afforded to damages received due to personal physical injuries or sickness and taxed as other income on the 1040.Business Damages: Business settlements can arise from various disputes related to business operations, and their tax treatment can have significant implications. The tax treatment of a business settlement depends on the origin of the claim. Settlements typically fall into categories such as compensation for lost profits, damages to business reputation, or recovery of capital.
Compensatory Damages - If the settlement compensates for lost profits, it is generally taxable as ordinary income. These are treated as income because they are effectively replacing income the business would have otherwise earned.
Punitive Damages - Punitive damages are taxable. They are intended to punish the defendant rather than compensate the plaintiff for any loss, and thus they are considered a windfall to the plaintiff.
Capital Recoveries - Settlements that compensate for the destruction or damage to a capital asset, such as business-related real estate or equipment, might reduce the asset's basis rather than be taxed as income. If it exceeds the adjusted basis of the asset, the remainder may be a capital gain.Interest and Property Settlements: Interest accrued on any settlement, even if the settlement proceeds aren’t taxable, is generally taxable as interest income. Meanwhile, settlements for the loss of property value that do not exceed the property's adjusted basis are not taxable. However, any excess over the adjusted basis becomes taxable.
Deductibility of Attorney Fees and Its Impact
Legal fees can significantly impact the net proceeds of a settlement. Whether attorney fees are deductible can alter the tax obligations associated with a settlement:
General Rule on Deductibility: Attorney fees incurred in securing a taxable personal settlement are generally not deductible.
Impact of Fees on Settlement Proceeds: If attorney fees are deducted from the award, the entire amount may still be required to be reported as income. For instance, if you receive a $100,000 settlement and pay $40,000 in attorney fees, you might still need to report the full $100,000 as income, regardless of netting only $60,000.
Exceptions: Some specific settlements might allow the deduction of attorney fees directly against the income, especially in discrimination or whistleblower lawsuits. In such cases, the deduction is allowed “above the line,” i.e., without having to itemize deductions, thus reducing adjusted gross income (AGI).
Business Settlements: In the case of a business settlement, attorney fees may be treated in different ways, depending primarily on the nature of the legal matter involved and whether the expenses can be directly tied to the production or collection of taxable income or the management, conservation, or maintenance of property held for the production of income. Here's a general overview:
o Deductible Expenses - If the attorney fees are ordinary and necessary expenses for managing, conserving, maintaining income-producing property, or for producing or collecting taxable income, they may be deductible. For instance, legal fees paid for advice on business operations, resolving tax issues, or performance under contracts related to income are generally deductible.
o Capital Expenses - Attorney fees that are paid to acquire a business asset, or are otherwise related to the acquisition, cannot be deducted immediately. Instead, they are considered capital expenses and are added to the basis of the asset. For example, legal fees for drafting or reviewing contracts for acquiring real estate or equipment would be capitalized and depreciated over the IRS-assigned life of the asset.
o Settlements Involving Nondeductible Expenses - In cases where the legal fees relate to settlements of a personal nature or non-deductible penalties, such fees are not deductible.
o Mixed-Use Expenses - If legal fees are incurred for both personal and business purposes, the fees must be allocated between deductible and non-deductible expenses based on the predominant purpose.
Strategic Considerations for Taxpayers
Given these tax complexities, taxpayers should consider several strategies:
Detailed Records: Maintain comprehensive documentation of all elements of the settlement and any deductions claimed (such as medical expenses related to emotional distress), which can be crucial if questioned by the IRS.
Settlement Structuring: When negotiating settlements, understanding and influencing how allocations are determined (e.g., more towards physical injuries than punitive damages) can have substantial tax implications.
Estimated Tax Payments: If the settlement significantly increases taxable income, taxpayers might need to make estimated tax payments to avoid underpayment penalties.
In conclusion, the taxation of lawsuit settlements is complex, with potential for both taxable and non-taxable components. Taxpayers should carefully evaluate the elements of their settlements, understand the tax implications, and take proactive steps to manage tax liabilities. By doing so, they can navigate the complexities of litigation-related tax obligations and maximize their financial outcomes post-settlement.
Due to the intricate nature of the tax laws surrounding settlements, it may be appropriate to consult with this office prior to agreeing to a settlement so you understand the tax ramifications as they will impact your tax return.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.
We care about the protection of your data.